Comeback Sauce

Are you looking for a perfect dipping sauce? We are here with an easy and quick recipe for Comeback sauce. It is a creamy and tangy sauce with a hint of spice that balances the overall flavor of the sauce.

You can pair Nashville Comeback sauce with various kinds of food items. For example, fried chicken, French fries, onion rings, fried shrimp, or even sautéed vegetables will pair perfectly with this versatile sauce.

This sauce truly stands out with its name, and you will keep coming back to this sauce again and again. We are here to share the easiest recipe for finger-licking Southern Comeback sauce. Don’t miss the end to get pro tips.

What is Comeback Sauce?

The Comeback sauce is a Southern condiment made with mayonnaise, ketchup, chili sauce, and spices. This sauce originated in Jackson, Mississippi. Many people compare the Southern Comeback sauce with Thousand Island dressing.

If you’re looking for a balanced, tangy, and spicy dipping sauce with a creamy texture, Comeback sauce can be an addictive option for you. This article will tell you how to make this finger-licking sauce at home.

Why You Will Love This Recipe?

The Comeback sauce can elevate the taste of our ordinary meals and is very quick to make. Its balanced flavor will make you a fan of this flavorful dipping sauce. Now, let me tell you why this sauce will be best for you:

• Supper Easy to Make

You only need to mix the ingredients in a bowl to make this Comeback sauce.  

• Versatile

This sauce will work as a dipping sauce for your fries, a spread for sandwiches, a sauce for burgers, grilled chicken, and even for roasted vegetables. 

• Balanced Flavor

The Comeback sauce is neither so spicy nor so tangy or sweet. It provides a balanced flavor. Therefore, everyone can enjoy this sauce with satisfaction. 

• Better than Store-Bought

The homemade comeback sauce provides fresh flavor, and it is preservative-free. Additionally, you can make the sauce exactly as you like with the help of a homemade version.

Comeback Sauce Recipe Ingredients

1. Mayonnaise – 1 cup

Mayonnaise provides the base of the Comeback sauce. If you want to avoid mayonnaise, you can use Greek yogurt as a substitute.   

2. Ketchup – ¼ cup

Ketchup adds a sweet and tangy flavor to the sauce. You can use chili sauce instead of ketchup to get a kick of spice. 

3. Hot Sauce – 2 tablespoons

Hot sauce provides the spicy flavor. Experts suggest using sriracha to add an excellent flavor profile. 

4. Worcestershire Sauce – 1 tablespoon

Worcestershire sauce is an essential ingredient to get umami depth. You can use soy sauce as a substitute. 

5. Dijon Mustard – 1 tablespoon

The Alabama Comeback sauce has a sharp flavor, which comes from the mustard. It also helps to give an attractive color to the sauce. You can add mustard paste if you don’t have Dijon mustard.  

6. Garlic Powder – 1 teaspoon

Garlic powder adds a nice aroma and flavor to the sauce. Freshly grated garlic can be a substitute for the powder. 

7. Onion Powder – 1 teaspoon

Onion powder is a complementary ingredient for garlic powder. It provides a sweet flavor and depth to the sauce. 

8. Black Pepper Powder – 1 teaspoon

Black pepper is an important ingredient in a sauce recipe. It provides spiciness and sharp flavor.   

9. Lemon Juice – 1 tablespoon

Lemon juice gives a tangy flavor and brightness. As a substitute for lemon juice, you can add white vinegar or apple cider vinegar. This ingredient also works as a natural preservative. 

10. Vegetable Oil – 2 tablespoons (Optional)

Professionals use vegetable oil to make the Comeback sauce to get the smooth and creamy texture.

How to Make Comeback Sauce Recipe: Easy 5 Steps?

This article aims to provide the easiest recipe for a homemade Comeback sauce recipe. Follow our steps to get the perfect and authentic comeback sauce instantly.

Step 1: Collect and Measure the Ingredients

Before starting the process, read the ingredient list carefully.

• Collect all the required ingredients.
• Then, measure them precisely according to the ingredient list.  

Step 2: Prepare the Sauce Base

Now, it’s time to prepare the sauce base.

• Take a medium-sized bowl.
• Add mayonnaise, ketchup, and vegetable oil to the bowl.
• Combine them nicely using a whisk.
• Take time to mix them well.
• Then add the hot sauce, Worcestershire sauce, and Dijon mustard to the bowl. 
• Again, mix them nicely.
• After getting a smooth texture, you can be sure that the sauce base is ready. 

Step 3: Add Seasoning Ingredients

The sauce base is ready. Now, you have to add seasoning ingredients to make the sauce flavorful.

• Stir in garlic powder, onion powder, and black pepper powder into the sauce base.
• Combine them nicely.  

Step 4: Taste and Adjust the Sauce

Adjusting the taste is a wonderful opportunity in homemade recipes.

• Take a spoonful of sauce and taste it.
• Then, you can adjust the taste according to your choice.
• You can add more hot sauce to get spicy Comeback sauce.
• The addition of extra lemon juice or vinegar will give a tangier flavor.
• You can add some sugar to balance the flavor.
• That’s how you can easily customize the taste. 

Step 5: Set the Sauce 

The Comeback sauce is ready. But you have to refrigerate the sauce to get the perfect texture.

• Cover the bowl and refrigerate it for at least 1 hour to let the flavors meld properly. 
• After 1 hour, the sauce is now ready to serve.

Pro Tips

• Use high-quality mayonnaise: Using high-quality mayonnaise is mandatory to get the perfect creamy texture.
• Add smoked paprika: You can add smoked paprika to get a smoky twist in the sauce.
• Chill the sauce: Don’t forget to chill the sauce before serving to get an authentic taste.
• Whisk nicely: Mixing is the key to getting the perfect Comeback sauce. Please take the time to mix the ingredients thoroughly. If you don’t have a whisk, you can use a spoon to mix the ingredients.  
• Store the sauce: Put the sauce in an airtight jar and keep this jar in a fridge to store the sauce for up to 1 week.

Is Comeback Sauce like Cane’s Sauce?

In the sense of consistency, the Comeback sauce and Cane’s sauce are quite similar. Both of them are used as dipping sauces.

But, in the context of flavor, these two sauces are quite different. Cane’s sauce is spicier and less tangy compared to the Comeback sauce. Besides, Comeback sauce is richer than Cane’s sauce, as it contains Dijon mustard.

However, both sauces are tasty and versatile. You will love both of them.